Salt water, lighting… bad journalism or fraud?

I keep seeing stories about a new lamp that is “powered” by salt water. The claim is that you’ll get 45 days of lighting using nothing more than half a liter of salt water…

What I want to know is why none of these journalists ever check with an engineer or physicist or high school science teacher on whether such a claim is possible. If it’s not obvious to you, the answer is no, salt water alone doesn’t produce electricity. If it did, every coastal city would just pull power from the ocean instead of burning coal and gas or bothering with wind and solar.

So is this bad journalism or outright fraud?

Dig into the details and it seems this device is powered by a non-obvious battery. Not your typical off-the-shelf battery, which would undoubtedly be less expensive than what powers this lamp. Nor a rechargeable battery and solar panel, which is what is now ubiquitous across the emerging markets. No, this device contains solid or powered magnesium and the salt water is the electrolyte conducting an electric current, just like a battery as that magnesium oxidizes.

What the journalists and company are ignoring is the fact that when the 45 days is over, no amount of fresh salt water is going to power the lamp again. To do that you need a new chunk of magnesium metal. What is the cost of that, and the environmental footprint of that? None of the articles bother to say.

What might that cost? You can order magnesium powder for $1 6 2 per kilogram on Alibaba today.

I like to think frauds like this don’t mean to be frauds, that the inventor instead had the idea of mixing water and magnesium to make power, made it work, got excited, and then didn’t care that the solution was 10x or 20x or 100x more expensive than the existing solutions, skipped over that flaw, and focused on the salt water instead.

But meanwhile, stories like this don’t get lights into homes that don’t have them, nor help fund real solutions to make that happen. So journalists, next time please take a few minutes to do your homework. Next time write the clickbait title of “45 day salt water lantern is a physics bending fraud” instead of making it sound real.

You have a decision to make. If you have seconds to decide, you go with your gut. If you have minutes, you might take that minute to weigh Plan A with Plan B. If you have weeks you might create a pro-con list to help decide between those two – or even three – options. If you have months, you might take the time to brainstorm for some out-of-the-box options. What most people overlook is that there...

A few months ago I was interviewed on a podcast where the key question was “What is your superpower?” Sounds innocuous and simple, but it was one of those moments to reflect on life and not just provide a truthful answer, but something interesting and thought provoking. My answer was “If only”. What if _____? I’ve been an entrepreneur for over thirty years, founding or co-founding 10 companies. I...

There are a lot of great posts buried in this blog’s archives that are still quite apt. Today is another reprise, this time revisiting the (often invisible) tradeoff between efficiency and resilience. Last time I explained that tradeoff with the case study of electricity blackouts in Texas and how that related to Google’s monopoly on search and Amazon’s dominance of eCommerce...

I’m in a reprise mood this season… recently thinking about a blog post from 2015 with a lesson learned in an old movie on how to blow up a dam. A lesson about the expectations when making a big change to the world. The lesson comes from Force 10 from Navarone, starring Harrison Ford and Robert Shaw. This is a movie I first saw on a Sunday afternoon on TV as a pre-teen, and then dozen...

“History Doesn’t Repeat Itself, but It Often Rhymes” (Twain). Wednesday, November 6th, and it feels a bit more repeat than rhyme. Eight years ago I posted Plan 11. It seems apt to reprise that post. 2016 Every event in Seattle this week seems to start with a lamentation of last week’s election results. Three days after posting about #lemonade and I’m getting more funny...